The Fine Line Interview: My Take on Rebranding, Heritage, and Authenticity

As EVP of Global Brand Strategy at Avenue Z, I break down when rebranding makes sense, how brands like Jaguar and Porsche successfully balance heritage with innovation, and why authenticity always wins in the long run.

At Avenue Z, I don’t see branding as a surface-level refresh—it’s a strategic evolution that keeps brands relevant while staying true to their DNA. In my recent interview with The Fine Line, I broke down when rebrands make sense, how heritage plays a role, and why authenticity always wins in the long run.

When Does a Rebrand Make Sense?

A rebrand isn’t a magic fix—it only works if a company’s identity no longer aligns with its values, audience, or market positioning.

“A rebrand makes sense when your identity no longer lines up with your values, audience, or market positioning.”

But let’s be clear—a new logo won’t fix deeper problems like poor product quality or internal misalignment. Sometimes, a strategic update—like Audi’s redesign to appeal to younger buyers—makes more sense than a full-scale overhaul.

Does Heritage Still Matter?

It’s not about choosing heritage or innovation—the strongest brands find a way to balance both.

“It’s not about picking heritage or innovation. It’s about crafting a story that’s consistent and actually resonates with people.”

Some brands that have done this well:
•Porsche
introduced the Taycan, tapping into its sports car legacy while going electric.
•Volvo brought back the classic road trip vibe in its recent brand refresh.
•Ford proved its Mustang still has staying power by testing it on Germany’s Nürburgring.

Nostalgia alone won’t carry a brand—but when used strategically, it’s a powerful tool.

The Jaguar Rebrand: Success or Misstep?

Jaguar’s new look has people talking—which, in itself, is a win. But is it enough?

“We’ll need six to twelve months of tracking sentiment, engagement, and revenue to really gauge its success.”

While media buzz is a great start, if customers feel disconnected or sales remain flat, the rebrand may not deliver. Ultimately, success comes down to authenticity and execution.

Mark Zuckerberg’s ‘Villain Era’ – Smart or Risky?

One of the most interesting parts of the interview was my take on Mark Zuckerberg’s shift in public image.

“He’s taking control of his own story, embracing the controversy, and steering the conversation his way.”

But with Meta’s recent layoffs, some critics question whether his brand contradictions will catch up to him. At the end of the day, brand stories don’t exist in a vacuum—what a company does internally will always impact public perception.

Managing Client Expectations in a Rebrand

I always keep it real with clients—here’s what a rebrand can and can’t do:

•Change doesn’t happen overnight – Shifting public perception takes months, not weeks.
•A rebrand won’t fix deeper internal issues – If there are bigger structural problems, a rebrand won’t solve them.
•You won’t win over everyone, and that’s okay – The goal isn’t to please everyone, it’s to connect with the right audience.

Final Takeaway: Authenticity Wins

I always come back to Richard Branson’s wisdom—brands that try to be “perfect” lose character and public trust. Staying true to a brand’s DNA is what builds lasting connections and real engagement. Read more in Filestage.

, ,

More from Avenue Z

  • Google’s AI Mode: A CMO’s Field Guide

    Google’s AI Mode is transforming search into a conversational, AI-driven experience—challenging traditional SEO and redefining how brands achieve visibility,…

    Link

    8 min read

    ,
  • Retro background futuristic landscape 1980s style. Vector perspective grid. 80s sci-fi or game style. Retro neon background

    Top Picks for Miami Tech Week 2025

    The Best Events for Founders, Investors, and Operators to Attend This April in Miami

    Link

    4 min read

    , ,
  • perplexity-llm-integration-feature

    Perplexity’s “Frenemies” Strategy is Boldly Centralizing the LLM Ecosystem

    In a world where every AI company is racing to outbuild the competition, Perplexity made a bold move. Instead…

    Link

    7 min read

    , ,
  • Top of Stack: Fintech, Media, and the Rise of Borderless Everything

    From borderless banking breakthroughs to AI risks in federal policy, here’s issue #002 of what’s shaping headlines across fintech,…

    Link

    4 min read

    , , ,
  • Floating island adventure magical sky travel with pink cloud reflection in water landscape beauty view

    The Third Great Digital Land Grab: Why AI Search is the Biggest First-Mover Advantage Since SEO

    AI search is rewriting the rules of digital visibility; brands that move now to build AI authority will dominate…

    Link

    7 min read

    , , ,
  • Transparent Glass Cubes in Abstract Floating Arrangement

    AI Search Loves Answers: How to Write FAQ-Driven Content for LLMs

    AI search engines prioritize answers, not just keywords. Brands that structure content in a FAQ-driven format are more likely…

    Link

    4 min read

    , ,
  • Neural network model. Artificial intelligence. AI

    The Top PR Firms for AI Companies

    These PR firms know how to position your AI company to get seen, cited, and clicked—driving real visibility and…

    Link

    7 min read

    ,
  • 3d render of surreal panoramic background. Abstract minimal wallpaper of fantastic landscape with glass eroded sphere, hills and reflection in the water.

    Top Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) Agencies of 2025

    Top GEO agencies of 2025 that are helping brands show up in AI-generated answers—and stay ahead of the curve.

    Link

    6 min read

    ,

Recommended reads

  • Google’s AI Mode: A CMO’s Field Guide

    Google’s AI Mode is transforming search into a conversational, AI-driven experience—challenging traditional SEO and redefining how brands achieve visibility,…

    Link

  • Retro background futuristic landscape 1980s style. Vector perspective grid. 80s sci-fi or game style. Retro neon background

    Top Picks for Miami Tech Week 2025

    The Best Events for Founders, Investors, and Operators to Attend This April in Miami

    Link

  • perplexity-llm-integration-feature

    Perplexity’s “Frenemies” Strategy is Boldly Centralizing the LLM Ecosystem

    In a world where every AI company is racing to outbuild the competition, Perplexity made a bold move. Instead…

    Link

  • Top of Stack: Fintech, Media, and the Rise of Borderless Everything

    From borderless banking breakthroughs to AI risks in federal policy, here’s issue #002 of what’s shaping headlines across fintech,…

    Link

  • Floating island adventure magical sky travel with pink cloud reflection in water landscape beauty view

    The Third Great Digital Land Grab: Why AI Search is the Biggest First-Mover Advantage Since SEO

    AI search is rewriting the rules of digital visibility; brands that move now to build AI authority will dominate…

    Link

  • Transparent Glass Cubes in Abstract Floating Arrangement

    AI Search Loves Answers: How to Write FAQ-Driven Content for LLMs

    AI search engines prioritize answers, not just keywords. Brands that structure content in a FAQ-driven format are more likely…

    Link

  • Neural network model. Artificial intelligence. AI

    The Top PR Firms for AI Companies

    These PR firms know how to position your AI company to get seen, cited, and clicked—driving real visibility and…

    Link

  • 3d render of surreal panoramic background. Abstract minimal wallpaper of fantastic landscape with glass eroded sphere, hills and reflection in the water.

    Top Generative Engine Optimization (GEO) Agencies of 2025

    Top GEO agencies of 2025 that are helping brands show up in AI-generated answers—and stay ahead of the curve.

    Link

  • 3d render of abstract detailed shape. Minimal futuristic background.

    AI Search Is Disrupting Entire Industries  –  Here’s Who’s Affected Most and What to Do About It

    Search isn’t just changing, it’s being rewritten by AI and if your brand isn’t showing up in AI-generated answers,…

    Link

  • Ostersund, Sweden - June 14, 2024: TikTok shop webpage. TikTok Shop is an e-commerce feature of the video hosting service TikTok.

    Best TikTok Shop Agencies of 2025: Who Can Actually Drive Sales

    Innovation moves fast, and scrutiny moves faster. These top crisis communications firms don’t just react—they anticipate, protect, and position…

    Link

Connect With Us

Stay in touch. Discuss your needs with us and see how we can help.