An eCommerce Marketer’s Take on the AppLovin Short Reports

Want a marketer’s real take on the AppLovin short reports? Here’s what actually matters for ecommerce brands.

Over the past few weeks, AppLovin ($APP) has been the target of not one, but three separate short seller reports—from Fuzzy Panda, Culper Research, and most recently, Muddy Waters Research. The latest, published on March 27, caused a sharp drop in AppLovin’s stock and outlined a series of serious allegations.

As someone who works in ecommerce marketing and has spent time analyzing AppLovin’s platform, I wanted to share my perspective—not as a financial analyst, but as someone who actively works with ad platforms and understands how conversions, retargeting, and attribution actually work in practice.

Disclaimer: This is not financial advice. I do own a small, non-material position in AppLovin stock (<1% of my portfolio) based on my belief in its advertising technology. I am not paid by AppLovin or any affiliated parties. All views here are my own.

Overview of Muddy Waters’ Report

Unlike previous reports, Muddy Waters came armed with data. They analyzed five Shopify brands advertising on AppLovin across verticals like apparel, beauty, and healthcare, tracking results from December 30, 2024 to February 16, 2025. Collectively, the brands generated $300 million in revenue across 37 million users—roughly $8.11 in revenue per user.

But what stands out most is that these are large brands, each doing around $446 million in annual GMV. That context is key to evaluating the claims.

Claim I: Only 3.4% of Users Had Clicks from AppLovin Ads

My Perspective: Without knowing the brands’ ad budgets or the percentage of site traffic from paid media, this 3.4% figure lacks context. For brands of this size, most conversions come from returning customers or subscribers—not new traffic. It’s misleading to expect a new channel like AppLovin to represent a huge share of total traffic.

Claim II: AppLovin Often Isn’t the First Click in the Conversion Path

My Perspective: Muddy Waters argues that 52% of purchases attributed to AppLovin on a last-click basis weren’t also first-clicks. This isn’t surprising—and actually, it’s better than you might expect.

AppLovin currently struggles with audience exclusions (i.e., it can’t reliably filter out existing customers or past site visitors). So yes, retargeting is happening. But for large brands that have already reached a significant portion of their addressable market, this is normal. The fact that more than half of conversions were both first and last click via AppLovin is impressive, not damning.

Also, retargeting Meta users on AppLovin? That’s how all platforms work. The real issue is AppLovin’s limited targeting controls, which could restrict scale—not prove fraud.

Claim III: Only 25–35% of Sales Are Incremental

My Perspective: This is a fundamental misunderstanding of what incrementality is. Muddy Waters assumes that only first-click purchases count as incremental, which is simply incorrect.

Incrementality means the ad caused the purchase—not whether it was the first touchpoint. You can drive incremental value through retargeting, returning customers, or existing users. Muddy Waters’ exclusion logic ignores how complex user journeys really are.

Structured testing (like holdout studies) is the only way to measure incrementality. AppLovin doesn’t claim to do this, but short sellers haven’t proven that the 25–35% figure reflects reality either.

Claim IV: 22.6% of Advertisers Churned in Q1 2025

My Perspective: Muddy Waters tracked pixel removals from 776 websites and found that 171 were no longer using AppLovin. However, this doesn’t account for lead-gen advertiser bans (which AppLovin itself initiated) or temporary pauses.

We’ve heard firsthand that some advertisers paused due to internal resourcing—not performance. In fact, many brands won’t scale new channels unless they have bandwidth to optimize for them. That doesn’t signal fraud—it’s just the reality of marketing ops.

Claim V: Persistent Identity Graphs (PIGs) Violate Apple’s TOS

My Perspective: This is a complex and serious allegation—and one that’s hard to prove without deep technical investigation. But many ecommerce brands use tools like Elevar to pass first-party data (like Facebook IDs) to ad platforms. That’s entirely permissible.

AppLovin’s CTO clarified that any data sent unintentionally is purged, and visual evidence was shared showing no Facebook ID transfers in certain use cases. It’s up to brands to decide where their data goes—not AppLovin acting unilaterally.

Claim VI: Circumventing Apple & Google Tracking Rules

My Perspective: If AppLovin were truly circumventing Apple and Google’s rules, it’s hard to believe it wouldn’t have been caught by now. We’ve seen both tech giants crack down heavily in recent years. A $100B+ company like AppLovin would be under the microscope already.

Claims of token switching and fingerprinting raise valid concerns, but we need forensic analysis—not speculation—to know what’s really happening.

As Fei Wang, CEO of Source Medium, put it:

Muddy Waters’s description of token changing across environments raises legitimate questions, but proving intentional circumvention versus standard technical implementation requires specialized forensic analysis. When evaluating these claims, we must distinguish between standard device signals used within privacy frameworks and true fingerprinting that creates persistent cross-app identifiers.

Claim VII: Unfair Advantage in Ad Auctions

My Perspective: AppLovin’s Axon 2 algorithm works—period. That’s why its ad revenue has quadrupled. If there’s evidence of foul play, regulators will surface it. But the growth makes sense based on what we’ve seen in performance.

Their placements are non-skippable, their algo is strong, and they’ve added legitimate scale to ecommerce campaigns.

Final Thoughts

Short reports are meant to drive down stock prices—and they often succeed, at least temporarily. But that doesn’t mean every claim holds water.

From an ecommerce marketer’s standpoint, many of Muddy Waters’ assertions lack the context needed to understand how ad platforms actually work. AppLovin has room to improve (particularly on targeting), but the claims about click paths, incrementality, and churn don’t reflect what seasoned marketers see in practice.

Until something concrete surfaces from Apple, Meta, or Google, it’s reasonable to assume AppLovin is operating within standard practice—and innovating in ways that other ad platforms should be watching closely.

Want to cut through the noise and make smarter media decisions?

At Avenue Z, we help brands navigate the complexities of ad tech, performance marketing, and platform changes—with strategy rooted in data, and creative that converts. Whether you’re testing new channels or scaling what works, our team knows what it takes to drive growth and accountability. Learn more about our approach to paid media, here.

Ready for an expert? Let’s talk.

Turn Spend Into Sales

From Meta to TikTok, we build performance media strategies that convert—using AI, commerce integration, and creative built to drive measurable revenue.

,

More from Avenue Z

  • What Are Shopify MCP Servers and Why They Matter for AI Commerce

    A closer look at the Summer ’25 Editions update—and what brands need to do now.

    Link

    4 min read

    , ,
  • Top of Stack: AI Energy, Bank Downgrades, and a Spotlight on Embedded Finance

    Your latest briefing on the trends shaping AI, finance, healthcare, and brand visibility in the headlines.

    Link

    2 min read

    ,
  • The Gap is making a comeback. Let’s talk about it.

    From Timothée in satin to a Lilo and Stitch collab, Gap is doing what few legacy brands can. It’s…

    Link

    5 min read

    , ,
  • International Business Machines Corp. (IBM) CEO, Arvind Krishna.

    Top of Stack: Smarter AI, Fintech Politics, and a Big Tech Power Shift

    Your weekly briefing on the trends driving fintech, innovation, and AI (plus the events worth showing up for).

    Link

    4 min read

    ,
  • The AI Visibility Index: Why Digital Banks Must Compete for Share of Voice in AI Search

    Generative AI is changing how consumers discover brands, and digital banks are now competing in a new arena: AI…

    Link

    5 min read

    ,
  • Composite trend artwork sketch image collage of businesswoman young lady work internet webpage ai bot generate data simulation technology.

    From SEO to AIO: What Still Works, What Doesn’t, and What You Need to Win in AI Search

    Let’s start with the good news: not everything you’ve built in SEO land needs to be torched.

    Link

    12 min read

    ,
  • ChatGPT Shopping: How to Get Your Ecommerce Store Listed and Ranked

    ChatGPT Shopping: How to Get Your eCommerce Store Ranked

    ChatGPT Shopping is changing how people find products online. This guide shows how to get your store listed, improve…

    Link

    7 min read

    , ,
  • Who Won Marketing at the F1 Miami Grand Prix?

    Which F1 teams won the marketing race at the 2025 Miami Grand Prix? We break down the boldest brand…

    Link

    4 min read

    , , ,
  • Artistic representation of people in Times Square for NFT NYC 2025.

    Top NFT NYC 2025 Must-Attend Events

    Get ready for NFT NYC 2025 with our guide to the top events where culture, tech, and community collide.

    Link

    3 min read

    , ,
  • Introducing the AI Visibility Index: Fintech Payments

    A data-driven look at which payment brands are leading in AI search and what it takes to become the…

    Link

    7 min read

    ,
  • Why AI Agents Are Already Rewriting Your eCommerce Brand Strategy with Jonathan Snow

    AI is already making purchase decisions. My latest Fast Company feature unpacks what that means for brand visibility, discovery,…

    Link

    2 min read

    ,
  • Manhattan Bridge in New York City, view from the street between brick buildings, New York City, Architectural photography.

    Top NY Tech Week 2025 Events We’re Eyeing (and You Should Too)

    These are the rooftop hangs, power walks, and pitch rooms you need to be in—bookmark this list, grab your…

    Link

    5 min read

    ,
  • Top of Stack: Markets, Media, and the March Toward Mayhem

    Get the press hits, trend intel, and event picks you need to stay ahead in fintech, innovation, and digital…

    Link

    3 min read

    ,
  • The Mirage of Simplicity in AI: Why Strategy Still Comes First

    AI can move fast and look smart—but without a clear strategy, it often just scales misalignment. Here’s why the…

    Link

    3 min read

    ,
  • Google’s AI Mode: A CMO’s Field Guide

    Google’s AI Mode is transforming search into a conversational, AI-driven experience—challenging traditional SEO and redefining how brands achieve visibility,…

    Link

    8 min read

    ,
  • Retro background futuristic landscape 1980s style. Vector perspective grid. 80s sci-fi or game style. Retro neon background

    Top Picks for Miami Tech Week 2025

    The Best Events for Founders, Investors, and Operators to Attend This April in Miami

    Link

    4 min read

    , ,
  • perplexity-llm-integration-feature

    Perplexity’s “Frenemies” Strategy is Boldly Centralizing the LLM Ecosystem

    In a world where every AI company is racing to outbuild the competition, Perplexity made a bold move. Instead…

    Link

    7 min read

    , ,
  • Top of Stack: Fintech, Media, and the Rise of Borderless Everything

    From borderless banking breakthroughs to AI risks in federal policy, here’s issue #002 of what’s shaping headlines across fintech,…

    Link

    4 min read

    , , ,
  • Floating island adventure magical sky travel with pink cloud reflection in water landscape beauty view

    The Third Great Digital Land Grab: Why AI Search is the Biggest First-Mover Advantage Since SEO

    AI search is rewriting the rules of digital visibility; brands that move now to build AI authority will dominate…

    Link

    7 min read

    , , ,
  • Transparent Glass Cubes in Abstract Floating Arrangement

    AI Search Loves Answers: How to Write FAQ-Driven Content for LLMs

    AI search engines prioritize answers, not just keywords. Brands that structure content in a FAQ-driven format are more likely…

    Link

    4 min read

    , ,

Recommended reads

  • What Are Shopify MCP Servers and Why They Matter for AI Commerce

    A closer look at the Summer ’25 Editions update—and what brands need to do now.

    Link

  • Top of Stack: AI Energy, Bank Downgrades, and a Spotlight on Embedded Finance

    Your latest briefing on the trends shaping AI, finance, healthcare, and brand visibility in the headlines.

    Link

  • The Gap is making a comeback. Let’s talk about it.

    From Timothée in satin to a Lilo and Stitch collab, Gap is doing what few legacy brands can. It’s…

    Link

  • International Business Machines Corp. (IBM) CEO, Arvind Krishna.

    Top of Stack: Smarter AI, Fintech Politics, and a Big Tech Power Shift

    Your weekly briefing on the trends driving fintech, innovation, and AI (plus the events worth showing up for).

    Link

  • The AI Visibility Index: Why Digital Banks Must Compete for Share of Voice in AI Search

    Generative AI is changing how consumers discover brands, and digital banks are now competing in a new arena: AI…

    Link

  • Composite trend artwork sketch image collage of businesswoman young lady work internet webpage ai bot generate data simulation technology.

    From SEO to AIO: What Still Works, What Doesn’t, and What You Need to Win in AI Search

    Let’s start with the good news: not everything you’ve built in SEO land needs to be torched.

    Link

  • ChatGPT Shopping: How to Get Your Ecommerce Store Listed and Ranked

    ChatGPT Shopping: How to Get Your eCommerce Store Ranked

    ChatGPT Shopping is changing how people find products online. This guide shows how to get your store listed, improve…

    Link

  • Who Won Marketing at the F1 Miami Grand Prix?

    Which F1 teams won the marketing race at the 2025 Miami Grand Prix? We break down the boldest brand…

    Link

  • Artistic representation of people in Times Square for NFT NYC 2025.

    Top NFT NYC 2025 Must-Attend Events

    Get ready for NFT NYC 2025 with our guide to the top events where culture, tech, and community collide.

    Link

  • Introducing the AI Visibility Index: Fintech Payments

    A data-driven look at which payment brands are leading in AI search and what it takes to become the…

    Link

  • Why AI Agents Are Already Rewriting Your eCommerce Brand Strategy with Jonathan Snow

    AI is already making purchase decisions. My latest Fast Company feature unpacks what that means for brand visibility, discovery,…

    Link

  • Manhattan Bridge in New York City, view from the street between brick buildings, New York City, Architectural photography.

    Top NY Tech Week 2025 Events We’re Eyeing (and You Should Too)

    These are the rooftop hangs, power walks, and pitch rooms you need to be in—bookmark this list, grab your…

    Link

  • Top of Stack: Markets, Media, and the March Toward Mayhem

    Get the press hits, trend intel, and event picks you need to stay ahead in fintech, innovation, and digital…

    Link

  • The Mirage of Simplicity in AI: Why Strategy Still Comes First

    AI can move fast and look smart—but without a clear strategy, it often just scales misalignment. Here’s why the…

    Link

  • Google’s AI Mode: A CMO’s Field Guide

    Google’s AI Mode is transforming search into a conversational, AI-driven experience—challenging traditional SEO and redefining how brands achieve visibility,…

    Link

  • Retro background futuristic landscape 1980s style. Vector perspective grid. 80s sci-fi or game style. Retro neon background

    Top Picks for Miami Tech Week 2025

    The Best Events for Founders, Investors, and Operators to Attend This April in Miami

    Link

  • perplexity-llm-integration-feature

    Perplexity’s “Frenemies” Strategy is Boldly Centralizing the LLM Ecosystem

    In a world where every AI company is racing to outbuild the competition, Perplexity made a bold move. Instead…

    Link

  • Top of Stack: Fintech, Media, and the Rise of Borderless Everything

    From borderless banking breakthroughs to AI risks in federal policy, here’s issue #002 of what’s shaping headlines across fintech,…

    Link

  • Floating island adventure magical sky travel with pink cloud reflection in water landscape beauty view

    The Third Great Digital Land Grab: Why AI Search is the Biggest First-Mover Advantage Since SEO

    AI search is rewriting the rules of digital visibility; brands that move now to build AI authority will dominate…

    Link

  • Transparent Glass Cubes in Abstract Floating Arrangement

    AI Search Loves Answers: How to Write FAQ-Driven Content for LLMs

    AI search engines prioritize answers, not just keywords. Brands that structure content in a FAQ-driven format are more likely…

    Link

  • Businesswoman Leads Meeting Around Table Shot Through Door

    Leadership Isn’t What It Used to Be (And That’s a Good Thing)

    In Fast Company’s latest feature, I shared why asking better questions, not having all the answers, is the new…

    Link

  • this A visual depiction of B2B e-commerce competitive analysis and market positioning.

    Why Your B2B Sales Pipeline Needs AI Optimization Now

    AI is changing how deals get done. In this Forbes feature, I break down what B2B brands need to…

    Link

Connect With Us

Stay in touch. Discuss your needs with us and see how we can help.